Part of the calculus behind any drawdown schedule will be the progress of peace negotiations with the Taliban. Yesterday, The Express Tribune, a Pakistani newspaper affiliated with The International Tribune, ran a story alleging that, according to an unnamed source, the United States had made direct contact with Taliban leader Mullah Omar via an intermediary, a former Taliban spokesman known as Mohammad Hanif who was arrested by U.S. forces in 2007.
Rumors on high-level secret negotiations between the U.S. and the Taliban have been swirling around Kabul for at least a year. Some of this hearsay could be credible, such as talks in Germany, the Persian Gulf and Turkey, while in others instances the U.S. has been outright hoodwinked by Taliban impostors.
According to the Express article, the U.S. had offered the Taliban control over the south of Afghanistan, while leaving the north for the other political forces under American influence. However, this was rejected by the Taliban.
Should this turn out to be true, it would seem the U.S. has taken a page from a recent Foreign Affairs article penned by Robert D. Blackwill, former U.S. ambassador to India and former deputy national security adviser for strategic planning.
In the article Blackwill writes:Current U.S. policy toward Afghanistan involves spending scores of billions of dollars and suffering several hundred allied deaths annually to prevent the Afghan Taliban from controlling the Afghan Pashtun homeland -- with little end in sight. Those who ask for more time for the existing strategy to succeed often fail to spell out what they think the odds are that it will work in the next few years, what amount of casualties and resources they think the attempt is worth, and why. That calculus suggests that it is time to shift to Plan B....The time has come, therefore, to switch to the least bad alternative -- acceptance of a de facto partition of the country.
Blackwill proposes a long term combat role for as many as 50,000 U.S. troops in the north half of the country, ceding the rest of the country to the Taliban. "...Washington should accept that the Taliban will inevitably control most of the Pashtun south and east and that the price of forestalling that outcome is far too high for the United States to continue paying," argues Blackwill. The former ambassador's proposal amounts to a decade of nation-building in the north and counterterrorism in the south.
If the U.S. is indeed offering to barter half of Afghanistan for a peace treaty, perhaps the Obama administration has reluctantly arrived at the same conclusion as Blackwill: "Accepting a de facto partition of Afghanistan has enough downsides that choosing it makes sense only if the other options available are even worse. They are."
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Is the US Offering Taliban Half of Afghanistan?
Real Clear World's Compass Blog noting a report in a Pakistani newspaper . . .
- ► 2012 (165)
- Osama's Victory
- Afghanistan: Night Raids and "Victory"
- Latest Libya War WTF Update
- Teaching a Pig How to Sing
- How Netanyahu Government Divides the Jewish People...
- Could War Break Out between Syria and Turkey?
- Hopeful Sign for Egypt's Democracy, and America's ...
- On the Afghan Withdrawal
- Afghanistan: from Express Lane to Exit Ramp. . . t...
- Thomas Friedman's "Third Party"
- A Half-a-Loaf Way Forward in Libya and Syria?
- Iraq: The Beat goes on . . . .
- Lindsey Graham and Wars in Syria and Libya
- More on Obama's "Not Hostilities" Dodge in Libya
- As Obama "De-Surges" Afghanistan, Bombings Kill Do...
- In Yemen, Are US Drone Attacks Buying Trouble for ...
- Discredited Neocons Ally with Obama on Libya War
- Message to McCain: It's the Economy, Stupid
- Can Pakistan Shut Down the Show?
- The Libya "Civil War" - and America's Unending One...
- Is the US Offering Taliban Half of Afghanistan?
- Some Hope for Republicans?
- No More Chance of US Staying in Iraq?
- Does Lindsey Graham Want US Boots on Pakistan's Gr...
- A Democracy Lesson for the US
- Iraq Going Its Own Way - Rohrabacher and the MEK
- The US's Iraq Withdrawal: Another Reason to Leave
- Approaching Armageddon? The World My Daughter's Ge...
- David Brooks' Warped Sense of "Normal"
- The American Way . . . to Third World Status
- Israel, Saudis, Turkey to US: "Suck on This"
- Some Historical Perspective on Bibi's Speech to Co...
- ▼ June (32)
- ► 2010 (305)
- ► 2009 (440)